Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Letters for The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas

Pavel to his family regarding living in the camp and working for Bruno's family.


To my dearest family,
Although the harsh endurance of the holocaust experience has taken its toll on the Jewish race, I have but a small window of opportunity to escape the horror. A slaves job is not easy, as well as the abuse from the soldiers, but is what price i have to pay to escape the camp and near death by gas. The delightful little boy, 'Master Bruno' is ever so kind and makes the whole day less agonising. His innocence is one to be admired, as well as his friendship and true self-of-sense which allows me to connect with him. His poor face and mind that has been effected by the evil soldier who attacked me. I now grow ill from the attack, my life is beginning to fade. I would love to hear you once more,
                                                                                            Pavel


Shmuel to his family back in Poland (if they were still alive) about his life in the camp and his best friend Bruno.


To mother and father,
This camp is horrible, i want to go home, i want to escape from here, i think i am going to die soon. The guards beat us, they yell at us, they treat us like dirt, whilst they live in fancy houses. I meet a nice boy though; my friend is Bruno. He is the same age as me and we have the same Birthday. He lives outside the camp; he is on the other-side of the fence. His father is a soldier, and he believes that he is a good, kind soldier, but i think all of the soldiers are mean. We both hate this one soldier though, Lt. Kotler. He is a bully and he picks on me and Bruno. Bruno is the only one who is nice to me and brings happiness to me. He doesn't understand a lot about my situation though, he doesn't know why i am in the camp. As much as i like Bruno, i want to be with you and free from this camp. Write back soon,
                                                                                        Shmuel

Sunday, September 4, 2011

Holocaust Art: "It Takes But One" by Elizabeth Denholm and Alyssa Dziurlaj

What visual techniques are employed in this painting?
Some of the visual techniques that are employed within the painting include; contrast, colour,
How do these visual techniques highlight major thematic elements of holocaust art and literature?

The use of contrast within the poster is used to heighten the difference between the blank faces and the Jews, the power of many compared to the single hand within the side and that one persons can make a difference. By the use of scale it does look like the big hand can give hope to a crowd of people. Also the use of the 'bleeding black' and that the faceless group that are doing nothing to help.

Daniel - Holocaust Poem

How is juxtaposition used in this poem to highlight an important them of Holocaust literature? The use of juxtaposition between the two people, the woman and the eight year old woman, to illustrate the two different status of people, one young and one old. This also shows the perspective of the boy and how the woman tries everything to protect him, innocence and compassion respectively. Innocence is a important and common theme in the holocaust genre and is often seen in the children who have 'built a barrier'. The boy within the story innocence comes from his view of the world ''he explained new events to her, that funny doggy, that pretty rock," and the woman's compassion comes from the way she describes the boy ''She vividly hears that little heartbeat, that was hers, always hers''.
How is descriptive language used to enhance the reader's reaction to the poem?
By using descriptive language within the poem the poem is enhanced and given more of a chance to connect with the reader. It also shows the compassion and innocence of the woman and boy respectively within the Jews and there ability to try and be happy even during dark times. It adds another element to the Holocaust genre and experience.

Chapter 15 - TBITSP

1. Why doesn't Bruno like Kotler? What does he observe and not understand about Kotler when his father is away? Bruno doesn't like Kotler because he is very negative towards him (such as he never smiles, always addressing Bruno as 'little man'), he is also acts in a very weird way to the rest of Bruno's family, i.e. sucking up to his father, flirting with his mother and always the attention of Gretel. Bruno observes him as being the man of the house when his father is out which annoys Bruno and that he is getting to close to his mother with helping to prepare for the surprise party and is past the point of merely being nice by helping.

2. What is meant when Kotler uses the cliche 'Don't worry, this one knows which side his bread is buttered on.'? This cliche means that he is sure that the person knows what he/she is talking about and he is sure they know what has to be done.

3. How would you describe the interaction between Kotler and Bruno? The interaction between Kotler and Bruno would be described as unique and different. There is obliviously tension between them which Bruno furthers with his attitude during there conversation. Kotler doesn't help the situation because he mocks Bruno with sarcastic jokes and thinks he is a little boy who doesn't know whats right for himself. They both try and get along but Kotler thinks he has dominance over Bruno which makes it hard for him.

4. What surprise does Bruno get? Bruno gets a very big surprise when he sees Shmuel in the kitchen in his kitchen cleaning glasses for the party tonight.

5. How is juxtaposition used when Bruno compares his hand to Shmuel's? 
Juxtaposition is used in contrasting Bruno and Shmuel as being clean and dirty respectively. Bruno is a clean cut boy who is healthy and happy as opposed to Shmuel who is under nourished, dirty and a skeleton like stature.

6. Does Bruno understand the pressure that Shmuel is under? Bruno doesn't understand the pressure Shmuel is user because him and Shmuel are friends which he in this situation is meant to be a servant. He than offers him food (Bruno thinking offering food to Shmuel would be polite) but Shmuel doesn't accept because he was told not to speak and clean glasses.

7. What dramatic situation unfolds and what is Bruno's reaction?  Bruno decides to be nice to Shmuel and give him some chicken, and Shmuel eats it. Lt. Kotler than notices it as he walks and gets very angry and asks Bruno about the situation and Bruno lies and says he has never seen him before in his life, mostly because he is scared of Lt. Kotler and what the consequences might be.

8.What does Bruno think of himself because of the way he reacts? How is the major theme 'fear' portrayed in this scene? What does it do to Bruno and Shmuel? Bruno thinks that he must be the meanest and worst friend in the world to Shmuel. The theme of 'fear' is portray heavily within the scene because the Bruno is in the situation because he feared Lt. Kotler and the consequences that follow it. Fear is also introduced to the two boys who even though are juxtaposed in there race, get along fine, but with Lt. Kotler comes fear. The fear destroys Bruno's and Shmuel's friendship and they don't talk for a while.

9. What does Bruno say that prompts Shmuel to offer his hand in friendship? How is this symbolic? Bruno says sorry to his friend Shmuel. He than explains why he acted the way he did which was because he was scared and acted like a coward. He than goes on to say that he would never to that to a friend which prompts there friendship and shows that they have made up and are now friends. This is symbolic because it shows the two races working in harmony even though the 'German' side of the equation had done wrong to the 'Jews'. Bruno also becomes less innocent as well because he becomes more aware of the people around him and there actions.

Chapter 14 - TBITSP

1. What information do we get that makes the reader start to feel that he is becoming less innocent and more ignorant? Shmuel tells Bruno about the striped pyjamas and why there where them. This causes Bruno to start complaining about the fact that he doesn't get to wear striped pyjamas and has to wear shirts, shorts and ties. This adds to innocence of Bruno and that he wants to wear pyjamas all day rather than boring clothes. This also relates to Bruno's lack of understanding of discipline outside his house and his lack of understanding of the camps.

2. What is interesting about the weather and how does it relate to the overall emotion of this stage in the book? The is interesting and a coincidence that it begins to rain and become all miserable during a very emotion stage during the book because at the time Pavel becomes very weak and Shmuel is being beaten within the camp.

3. What does Bruno accidentally say to Gretel? "I hate the rain too, I should be with Shmuel by now. He'll think I've forgotten him" is accidentally said to Gretel and is very crucial because he is not meant to be talking to the jews.

4. Is Bruno able to consider Gretel's feelings? How do you know? Bruno is able to consider Gretel's feelings to an exempt because he thinks she to must be bored at Auschwitz as all she has to do is rearrange her dolls. He thinks that she would rather be playing with her friends, as he would, back in Berlin. He feels he must talk to Gretel because he suspects they both are bored.

5. What is it that motivates Bruno not to tell Gretel the truth? How does this portray Bruno as being selfish? Bruno is motivated to not tell the truth to Gretel because he thinks that Shmuel will be taken from him and Gretel would make him her friend. This shows that Bruno has an ignorant and selfish attitude towards Gretel and wants Shmuel all to himself.

6. What is it that Bruno realises when he starts recounting what Shmuel tells him? Why do you think that this is when he finally starts to realise what Shmuel is experiencing? 
Bruno begins to put the pieces together and recounts the stories in which Shmuel tells him and releases how sad Shmuel's story is about his grandfather and that he can't be found within the camp. He begins to lose his innocence and understand Shmuel's point of view rather than trying to relate his view with his own. He also becomes more sensitive to others feelings rather than his own and begins to realises to listen to others.

7. What is ironic and hypocritical about what Gretel tells Bruno regarding imaginary friends? It is ironic because Gretel thinks that it is childish to have an imaginary friend when she has created her own within her dolls. It is also hypocritical because she thinks it is childish when she does it, and she is only thirteen.

Chapter 13 - TBITSP

1. How does the initial paragraph frame Bruno's state of mind? Bruno's entail change of mind is changing because of his focus on Shmuel and that he is spending so much time with him rather than complaining about leaving Berlin.

2. What does the question Bruno asks Maria show about his development?
 Bruno asks Maria about Pavel and if he really did use to be a doctor or is he a waiter for the family. By asking this it shows his development as a person and the separation between the standard nazi german and that he doesn't just ignore information put forward and is persistent and seeking the truth

3. What is important about Maria's reaction to Bruno's question?
  It is  important to the story because for the first time gives another point of view of family and also shows more juxtaposition within the story (i.e. Kotler and Maria) and another division of the family.

4. Why does Bruno want to tell Shmuel about Pavel? What does this highlight about Bruno's understanding of what is going on? Bruno wants to tell Shmuel about Pavel because he wants to know if there is a link between them. This also highlights that Bruno has to understand some factors about the jews and that they had jobs before they arrived there.

5. What do the boys argue about? Who does Bruno defend? Who is right/wrong? Why? Shmuel and Bruno begin to argue about the soldiers and whether or not they are good or bad. Bruno does think that some soldiers are bad, but also good because he thinks his father is good. Shmuel however thinks that all the soldiers are bad. I believe that they both are right because they would be some good soldiers that Shmuel may have not meet (not assigned to deal with the jews) but there is undoubtedly bad soldiers. Also, the point of view is heavily based upon there nationality as well for example, a proud Nazi thinks they are good and that the Holocaust is good as opposed to a jews point of view.


6. Shmuel says 'You don't know what it's like here.' and Bruno reacts by saying 'You don't have any sisters, do you?' He says this to avoid an answer to Shmuel. What does this show about Bruno's understanding of what is happening? Bruno is beginning to understand the darkness behind the fence and wants to hold on to the innocence he has but it is beginning to fade. This also shows that he is getting more information, a key aspect which is hid for most Germans to conceal the darkness of the camps. He also doesn't want to get involved with his father and his work because he also suspects his dad is involved.

7. What connection do the boys have regarding Lt. Kotler? The boys connections to Lt. Kotler is that both believe that he is a bully and a mean person. They are also frightened of him a and that he is a generally bad man.

8. What has changed in the the way Bruno sees Pavel? Bruno begins to notice Pavel as a person and everything he does around the house such as waitering for the family, rather a  'slave'. He also, rather than looking past him and never notice him, begins to notice everything he does in detail. He also begins to view Pavel over a week to week basis.

9. What important words are used to describe the way the father eats and addresses Bruno? What makes them important? How do they relate to the scene and the father as a character? Bruno's father's way of eating is described as 'attacking a leg of lamb' which shows the way in which he approaches factors in his life. Not only did he 'attack' his food but he also pointed with a knife and shrugged his shoulders which are both considered in-polite. This shows the authority of Bruno's father and that he is has no rules within there household.

10. We learn Lt. Kotler's first name - 'Kurt'. What is it about the sounds in his full name that are important? 'Kurt Kotler' By giving the name 'Kurt' to Lt. Kotler it adds upon the metaphor of him being the perfect Nazi German as he already has blonde hair, blue eyes and now has a alliterate name.
11. What do we learn about Kotler's father? What is Bruno's father's reaction/suggestion regarding Kotler's father leaving Germany for Switzerland?  We learn a very important fact about Kotler which is that his father is a teacher who moved out of Germany to Switzerland in 1938. Bruno's father's reaction is that he feels insulted and that Kotler's father would leave Germany and even during a time of her uprising.

12. What happens to break the tension at the dinner table? What does Kotler do and what are everyone's reactions? What does Bruno decide regarding disagreeing with anyone anymore after seeing what happens to Kotler? What does this relate to historically in regards to the Nazis?' A wine bottle is dropped by Pavel which breaks the tension at the table. Most of the wine is spilt over Kotler and he gets very angry and beats him up which causes Gretel to go white and Bruno to start to cry. Bruno then decides that he not disagree with anyone or complain to anyone anymore. He does this because he thinks that he would get yelled at like Pavel by Kotler or similar and decides better keep his mouth shut. This historically relates to the Nazis and there contempt with power over the Jews and that even other Germans fear powerful military based Nazis.

Thursday, September 1, 2011

Angus Macrae Evaluation


  • Participation Contributes with relevant 'one-word' answers, but only when needed and not any depth
  • What questions/answers they ask The questions he asked is very relevant but in some instances are badly worded, answered question that was very important
  • Do they know what they are talking about He does know what he is talking about because his questions are relevant and show the depth in his answers however doesn't contribute in a minimal range
  • Overall what is your impression of their understanding of what is happening in the chapter  I believe he does have a good understanding of the chapter as seen through his comments to the juxtaposition between Shmuel and Bruno, and there journey to Auschwitz 
  • Mark - 8.5/10